|  
    
 NB1282

EMARK认证

 产品检测

  GS认证

 FDA认证

 

  您好,欢迎您登陆上海欧杰官方网站! 意大利ECM认证检测机构中国区代理!

 
关键词:CE认证,FDA认证,MDR认证
 
您当前位置: >> 欧盟MDR认证 >> 浏览文章

MDR合规必看|PMCF调查的伦理审查与知情同意,能豁免吗?

日期:2026-03-30 10:33:57 来源:本站原创   【字体:

对于布局欧盟市场的医疗器械制造商而言,上市后临床跟踪(PMCF)是绕不开的MDR合规核心——它不仅是EU MDR(EU)2017/745的关键要求,更是确保器械全生命周期持续安全、性能达标的“长效保障”。

不同于上市前的集中验证,PMCF要求制造商在器械投放市场后,持续主动收集、评估临床数据,确认安全性与性能、识别未知风险、监测副作用,确保收益-风险比始终可控。而随着MDR对PMCF的要求愈发严格,所有风险类别的器械都需主动开展数据收集,一个关键疑问也随之而来:
若PMCF调查是非干预性的,仅收集基于标准临床实践的匿名数据,能否豁免正式知情同意和伦理审查?
这一问题直接关系到PMCF计划的合规落地与执行成本,今天我们结合MDR条款、MDCG指南、GDPR及欧盟成员国要求,为大家拆解核心答案、梳理实操要点。

先明确:PMCF调查≠临床研究,豁免需看“性质”

首先要厘清一个关键边界:EU MDR对“临床研究”的定义是“涉及人类受试者、旨在评估器械安全或性能的系统性研究”,这既包括上市前研究,也包括上市后的PMCF研究,但并非所有PMCF活动都属于“临床研究”
MDR明确区分了PMCF的“一般方法”(如文献综述、用户反馈收集)和“特定方法”(如PMCF研究、注册数据利用)。而我们关注的“非干预性匿名调查”,可能属于其中任何一类——这也是能否豁免伦理审查和知情同意的核心前提。
简单来说:如果调查仅收集医疗从业者的常规使用反馈,不涉及患者特定数据、不改变临床诊疗流程,那么它大概率不属于需要严格遵守临床研究要求的PMCF研究,豁免的可能性更高;反之,若涉及患者临床数据、可能间接识别个人,就需按更严格的标准执行。

关键条款拆解:MDR第74条的“弹性空间”

很多人误以为MDR第74条(针对CE认证器械的临床研究)要求“伦理委员会必须全程参与”,但实际并非绝对。
第74条将PMCF研究分为两种情况:

  • 1. 评估器械“预期用途范围内”的研究:若不涉及额外的侵入性、负担性程序(比如非干预性匿名调查),伦理委员会的参与程度由成员国法规决定——部分国家可能仅要求“伦理咨询”,而非完整的伦理委员会批准;
  • 2. 评估器械“预期用途范围外”的研究:需完全遵守MDR第62-81条要求,伦理审查和知情同意不可豁免。

这里的核心结论是:非干预性、无额外负担的匿名调查,不必然需要完整的伦理审查和正式知情同意,但具体需结合所在成员国的法规要求判断,不能一概而论。

MDCG指南:4级vs8级调查,豁免要求大不同

医疗器械协调小组(MDCG)在2020-6号指南中,将PMCF调查按证据水平分为不同等级,其中与我们相关的是4级和8级,两者的伦理要求差异显著:

  • 4级调查:旨在解决特定临床数据缺口,需遵循ISO 14155标准,通常需要伦理委员会批准,且必须符合GDPR要求——这类调查多涉及具体临床结果数据,豁免难度大;
  • 8级调查:旨在收集一般性数据(如医疗从业者的使用体验、记忆中的临床反馈),监管要求更宽松。若仅收集从业者数据、不涉及任何患者识别信息,通常可豁免伦理委员会批准。

也就是说,若你的PMCF调查属于“不涉及患者数据、仅收集常规使用反馈”的8级调查,豁免伦理审查和正式知情同意的可能性极高;若属于4级调查,则需严格按要求执行。

GDPR加持:匿名化是“豁免关键”,但门槛极高

在数据收集层面,GDPR与MDR的衔接尤为重要——能否豁免知情同意,核心看数据是否达到“真正的匿名化”。
根据GDPR第26条,真正匿名化的数据(无法通过任何现有技术重新识别个人),不受GDPR约束,无需获得知情同意;但如果数据仅为“假名化”(用代码替换个人信息,但仍可间接识别),则仍属于个人数据,需遵守GDPR要求,通常需要知情同意。
这里需要注意:实现“真正的匿名化”难度极大,需确保没有任何合理手段能重新识别个人(包括考虑识别所需的成本、时间和现有技术)。即使数据达到匿名化,部分伦理委员会仍可能要求参与监督,确保匿名化过程合规、无泄露风险。

伦理委员会:最终决定权在“当地”

伦理委员会的核心职责是保护受试者的权利、安全和福祉,其参与程度最终由调查的具体设计和当地监管环境决定。
需要明确的是:

  • 1. 若调查涉及额外侵入性、负担性程序,必须获得伦理委员会的有利意见(如德国要求,需先通过伦理审查,才能向监管机构提交申请);
  • 2. 若为非干预性匿名调查,伦理委员会可根据具体情况,决定是否豁免正式审查和书面知情同意——但这一决定是“逐案判断”,没有统一标准;
  • 3. 不同欧盟成员国的伦理委员会对法规的解释存在差异,最终豁免与否,以当地伦理委员会的意见为准。

实操建议:6步确保PMCF调查合规豁免

结合上述分析,若你计划开展非干预性匿名PMCF调查,想要合规豁免伦理审查和正式知情同意,可按以下步骤操作:

  1. 明确定义调查类型:明确调查目标、数据收集方式,判断是否属于MDCG 2020-6中的8级调查,确认数据匿名化程度(是否达到GDPR要求);
  2. 主动咨询当地伦理委员会:向调查所在成员国的伦理委员会提交方案,明确咨询是否可豁免、豁免条件是什么;
  3. 完善PMCF计划论证:在计划中详细说明豁免理由,包括调查的非干预性、匿名化程序、器械现有临床证据等,证明豁免不会影响受试者权益;
  4. 严格遵守当地法规:不同成员国可能有额外要求(如部分国家要求“患者告知”),需逐一确认并落实;
  5. 做好患者告知准备:即使豁免正式知情同意,也建议制定简单的告知程序,保障透明度和患者知情权;
  6. 完整记录沟通过程:将与伦理委员会、监管机构的沟通记录、反馈意见、批准文件等全部留存,作为合规证明。

最后总结

非干预性匿名PMCF调查的伦理审查与知情同意,没有“一刀切”的豁免答案:核心取决于调查类型(4级/8级)、数据匿名化程度(真正匿名/假名化)、所在成员国法规,以及当地伦理委员会的判断。
对于医疗器械制造商而言,与其纠结“能否豁免”,不如先按合规要求梳理调查方案,主动咨询当地伦理委员会和监管机构——这既是MDR的要求,也是规避合规风险、确保PMCF数据被公告机构认可的关键。
毕竟,PMCF的核心是“保障器械安全”,而伦理合规与数据保护,正是这一核心的重要支撑。

如果需要进一步梳理你的PMCF调查类型,或解读某一成员国的具体伦理要求,可在评论区留言交流~

文献参考:

 

  1. Why the PMCF is so crucial under EU MDR? – ECLEVAR MedTech, medical device CRO,  
    https://www.eclevarmedtech.com/en/why-the-pmcf-is-so-crucial-under-eu-mdr/

  2. The Medical Device Practical Guide to PMCF Requirements under EU MDR,  
    https://www.greenlight.guru/blog/practical-guide-to-the-pmcf-requirements-of-the-eu-mdr

  3. PMCF Post-Market Clinical Follow-up | MDR Compliance Guide …,  
    https://www.mantrasystems.co.uk/eu-mdr-compliance/post-market-clinical-follow-up-pmcf

  4. Guide to Post-Market Clinical Follow-up Requirements Under EU MDR (2017/745) – NAMSA,  
    https://namsa.com/resources/blog/guide-to-post-market-clinical-follow-up-eu-mdr/

  5. The Importance of PMCF for Medical Devices – Celegence,  
    https://www.celegence.com/importance-post-market-clinical-follow-up-medical-devices-compliance/

  6. EU MDR PMCF Requirements for Medical Devices,  
    https://www.orielstat.com/blog/eu-mdr-pmcf/

  7. PMCF studies: framework and principles for medical devices – Efor Group,  
    https://efor-group.com/en/importance-and-design-of-pmcf-studies-for-medical-devices-in-europe-framework-and-principles/

  8. Post-Market Clinical Follow-up: Best Practices for PMCF – Regulatory knowledge for medical devices – Johner Institute,  
    https://blog.johner-institute.com/regulatory-affairs/post-market-clinical-follow-up-pmcf/

  9. PMCF Plan and PMCF Report under MDR What You Should Know – Clinical Evaluation Navigator,  
    https://clinicalevaluationnavigator.com/pmcf-plan-and-pmcf-report-under-mdr-2017-745-what-you-should-know/

  10. english.ccmo.nl,  
    https://english.ccmo.nl/investigators/clinical-investigations-with-medical-devices/legal-framework-guidances-and-standards-for-clinical-investigations-with-medical-devices/clinical-investigations-definition-and-framework#:~:text=Definition%20clinical%20investigation,performance%20of%20a%20medical%20device.

  11. Medical device clinical investigations — What’s new under the MDR? – BSI,  
    https://www.bsigroup.com/globalassets/localfiles/en-gb/medical-devices/whitepapers/clinical-investigations-update/clinical-investigation-update.pdf

  12. Introduction to clinical investigations of medical devices,  
    https://www.dmp.no/en/medical-devices/clinical-investigation-of-medical-devices/introduction-to-clinical-investigation-of-a-medical-device

  13. Variations in FDA and EU MDR Clinical Investigations – StarFish Medical,  
    https://starfishmedical.com/resource/variations-between-fda-and-eu-mdr-clinical-investigations/

  14. Clinical investigations: definition and framework,  
    https://english.ccmo.nl/investigators/clinical-investigations-with-medical-devices/legal-framework-guidances-and-standards-for-clinical-investigations-with-medical-devices/clinical-investigations-definition-and-framework

  15. Medical device clinical investigations – What’s new under the MDR?,  
    https://www.medical-device-regulation.eu/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/Clinical_Investigation_Revised_v2.pdf

  16. Understanding the Post-market Clinical Investigation Under the EU MDR 2017/745 | Freyr,  
    https://www.freyrsolutions.com/blog/understanding-the-post-market-clinical-investigation-under-the-eu-mdr-2017745

  17. ISO 14155: How It Impacts PMCF Investigations Under the MDR,  
    https://www.castoredc.com/blog/iso14155-pmcf-mdr-impact/

  18. How to write a comprehensive PMCF Plan for medical devices under the Medical Device Regulation (MDR) – Milo Healthcare,  
    https://milo-healthcare.com/en/how-to-write-a-comprehensive-pmcf-plan-for-medical-devices-under-the-medical-device-regulation-mdr/

  19. Harnessing the Power of Clinical Data with Post-Market Clinical Follow-Up Activities,  
    https://premier-research.com/perspectives/harnessing-the-power-of-clinical-data-with-post-market-clinical-follow-up-activities/

  20. Understanding the requirements of PMCF – BSI,  
    https://www.bsigroup.com/globalassets/meddev/localfiles/en-gb/webinars/bsi-md-clinical-masterclass-pmcf-under-mdr-webinar-160322-en-gb.pdf

  21. Medical Device Regulation (MDR) and the Documents required for Post Market Phases,  
    https://prineos.com/en/blog/medical-device-regulation-mdr-and-the-documents-required-for-post-market-phases/

  22. PMS and PMCF Activities for Medical Devices Under the MDR – QbD Group,  
    https://www.qbdgroup.com/en/blog/pms-and-pmcf-activities-for-medical-devices-under-the-mdr?hsLang=en

  23. white-paper-eu-pmcf-studies.pdf – Emergo,  
    https://www.emergobyul.com/sites/default/files/2022-07/white-paper-eu-pmcf-studies.pdf

  24. When, Why, and How to Use Post-Market Clinical Follow-Up (PMCF) Surveys – NAMSA,  
    https://namsa.com/resources/blog/when-why-and-how-to-use-post-market-clinical-follow-up-pmcf-surveys/

  25. Notification of a Post-Market Clinical Follow-up investigation in accordance with Article 74(1) of Regulation (EU) 2017/745 (MDR) – BfArM,  
    https://www.bfarm.de/EN/Medical-devices/Tasks/Clinical-investigations-and-performance-studies/Clinical-investigations/Notification-post-market-pmcf-kp/_artikel.html

  26. MDR – Article 74 – Clinical investigations regarding devices bearing …,  
    https://www.medical-device-regulation.eu/2019/07/15/mdr-article-74-clinical-investigations-regarding-devices-bearing-the-ce-marking/

  27. MDR requirements for PMCF investigations – BSI Compliance Navigator,  
    https://compliancenavigator.bsigroup.com/en/medicaldeviceblog/mdr-requirements-for-pmcf-investigations/

  28. PMCF studies and Article 74 of the MDR – medXteam,  
    https://www.medxteam.de/en/medxteam-blog/pmcf-studies-and-article-74-of-the-mdr

  29. PMCF studies: three types to be distinguished – Regulatory knowledge for medical devices,  
    https://blog.johner-institute.com/regulatory-affairs/pmcf-studies-three-types-to-be-distinguished/

  30. MDR 2017/745 Post-Market Follow-up – PMCF Clinical investigation – Eclevar Medtech,  
    https://www.eclevarmedtech.com/en/mdr-2017-745-art-74-1-post-market-follow-up-pmcf-clinical-investigation-with-medical-devices-submissions-in-germany/

  31. MDCG 2021-6 rev.1 – Public Health,  
    https://health.ec.europa.eu/system/files/2023-12/mdcg_2021-6_en.pdf

  32. PMS data: When you need an ethics committee – Regulatory knowledge for medical devices,  
    https://blog.johner-institute.com/regulatory-affairs/pms-data-ethics-committee/

  33. MedTech Digital Week PMCF Clinical Investigations and Other Studies 04 Oct 2022 – Question and Answers,  
    https://www.eclevarmedtech.com/en/medtech-digital-week-pmcf-clinical-investigations-and-other-studies-04-oct-2022-question-and-answers/

  34. PMCF Surveys – Evnia,  
    https://www.evnia.dk/pmcf-surveys/

  35. Tips to Design a High-Quality PMCF User Survey – Qserve CRO,  
    https://qservecro.com/tips-to-design-a-pmcf-high-quality-user-survey/

  36. MDCG endorsed documents and other guidance – European Commission – Public Health,  
    https://health.ec.europa.eu/medical-devices-sector/new-regulations/guidance-mdcg-endorsed-documents-and-other-guidance_en

  37. MDCG 2020-8 – Public Health,  
    https://health.ec.europa.eu/system/files/2020-09/md_mdcg_2020_8_guidance_pmcf_evaluation_report_en_0.pdf

  38. MDCG 2024-3 Guidance on content of the Clinical Investigation Plan for clinical investigations of medical devices – Public Health,  
    https://health.ec.europa.eu/document/download/690de85a-ac17-45ea-bb32-7839540c25c4_en?filename=mdcg_2024-3_en_0.pdf

  39. 4 Scenarios When High Risk Devices May Be Exempt from Mandatory Clinical Investigations Under EU MDR | Premier Research,  
    https://premier-research.com/perspectives/4-scenarios-when-high-risk-devices-may-be-exempt-from-mandatory-clinical-investigations-under-eu-mdr/

  40. EU MDR PMCF: To Waive or Not to Waive – ComplianceAcuity,  
    https://www.complianceacuity.com/eu-mdr-pmcf-to-waive-or-not-to-waive/

  41. Clinical investigations of medical devices under the MDR – The regulatory pathway,  
    https://blog.johner-institute.com/regulatory-affairs/clinical-investigations-of-medical-devices/

  42. Observational PMCF study – Eclevar Medtech,  
    https://www.eclevarmedtech.com/en/observational-pmcf/

  43. ANONYMISATION – European Data Protection Supervisor,  
    https://www.edps.europa.eu/system/files/2021-04/21-04-27_aepd-edps_anonymisation_en_5.pdf

  44. PREPARING FOR THE EU GDPR IN RESEARCH SETTINGS – Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health,  
    https://publichealth.jhu.edu/sites/default/files/2023-09/gdprapplication-in-research-settings-1.pdf

  45. What are the Differences Between Anonymisation and Pseudonymisation | Privacy Company Blog,  
    https://www.privacycompany.eu/blog/what-are-the-differences-between-anonymisation-and-pseudonymisation

  46. Should my medical device comply with GDPR? – MDRC,  
    https://mdrc-services.com/medical-devices-and-gdpr/

  47. THE GENERAL DATA PROTECTION REGULATION (“GDPR”) IN HUMAN SUBJECTS RESEARCH (“HSR”) What is the GDPR? Effective May 25, 2 – JHURA,  
    https://jhura.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/GDPR-QA.pdf

  48. Anonymization and GDPR compliance; an overview,  
    https://www.gdprsummary.com/anonymization-and-gdpr/

  49. What’s new for Data Privacy under Medical Device Regulation? – MyData-TRUST,  
    https://www.mydata-trust.com/2021/12/medical-device-regulation/10214/

  50. How Does the EU GDPR Impact Medical Device Clinical Trials? – Greenlight Guru,  
    https://www.greenlight.guru/blog/how-eu-gdpr-impacts-medical-device-clinical-trials

  51. Recital 26 – Not Applicable to Anonymous Data – General Data …,  
    https://gdpr-info.eu/recitals/no-26/

  52. Can Europe unlock the power of data while protecting privacy?,  
    https://www.medtecheurope.org/medtech-views/policy-views/can-europe-unlock-the-power-of-data-while-protecting-privacy/

  53. GDPR Brief: can genomic data be anonymised? – GA4GH,  
    https://www.ga4gh.org/news_item/can-genomic-data-be-anonymised/

  54. GDPR and unstructured data: is anonymization possible? – Oxford Academic,  
    https://academic.oup.com/idpl/article/12/3/184/6552802

  55. Q&A: PMCF User Feedback Surveys – RQM+,  
    https://www.rqmplus.com/blog/qa-pmcf-user-feedback-surveys

  56. Regulation (EU) 536/2014 and the role of ethics committees: a proposal for a review system model,  
    https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11552528/

  57. PMCF: Post Market Clinical Follow-Up & MDCG’s Latest Guidance,  
    https://citemedical.com/post-market-clinical-follow-up-pmcf-understanding-mdcgs-latest-guidance/

  58. QA data protection and clincial trials_for consulation final – Public Health,  
    https://health.ec.europa.eu/document/download/c3042973-b36d-4094-a1fb-a6fc980f065e_en

  59. Ethics and data protection – European Commission,  
    https://ec.europa.eu/info/funding-tenders/opportunities/docs/2021-2027/horizon/guidance/ethics-and-data-protection_he_en.pdf

上一篇:EUDAMED:如何避免上传 BASIC UDI-DI 时出现错误 下一篇:医疗器械合规评估入门路线图
 
 

相关文章:

 
返回首页

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
精品认证
 
 欧盟MDR认证
 
 美国FDA认证
 
 中国CFDA认证
 
 GMP认证
 
 ISO13485认证
 
  
 
联系方式
电话:021-37829967
      021-37633862
传真:021-37633862
QQ:   1206693898
微信:18602151536
邮箱: info@ou-jie.com
业务联系: 黄经理
 
 

 
 

沪公网安备 31011702004097号